Xiaomi’s Mi Band and Huawei’s Band line of merchandise have for a lot of generations now duked it out within the inexpensive health tracker house with very related options and totally different type elements, all geared in direction of taking the crown as the very best health tracker.
In 2023, each Huawei and Xiaomi have their Band 8 units vying for the highest spot. So for somebody that’s seeking to get one in every of these, which one tops the opposite? Which is the one to get? Over the previous month, I’ve been utilizing the Huawei Band 8 and the Xiaomi Good Band 8 alternatingly and on this submit, I take you thru my ideas that can assist you resolve which one to get.
Commercial – Proceed studying under
Associated:
Value noting straight off the bat is that these units have been evolving slowly through the years and so they each supply a variety of options and features that make them commerce blows on virtually all necessary elements so whichever you find yourself selecting, you might be getting a fairly refined gadget.
Specs
Huawei Band 8 and Xiaomi Good Band 8 are each wonderful health trackers with their very own distinctive options. Here’s a comparability of the 2:
| Function | Huawei Band 8 | Xiaomi Good Band 8 |
|---|---|---|
| NFC | Sure | No |
| Name Management | Sure | Sure |
| Stroke Counter for Swimming | Sure | No |
| Thickness | 8.99mm | 10.99mm |
| Cost Time | 0.75h | 1h |
| Display Dimension | 1.47″ | 1.62″ |
| Battery Life | 14 days | 16 days |
| Battery Energy | 180mAh | 190mAh |
| Dustproof and Waterproof | No | Sure |
| Irregular Coronary heart Charge Warnings | No | Sure |
Design
The Huawei Band 8 and the Xiaomi Good Band 8 each stick with their predecessors type issue for probably the most half. They each spot rectangular screens and a silicone strap that may be changed with totally different colours and kinds.
Each units are light-weight and cozy to put on, and they’re water resistant as much as 50 meters. Nevertheless, there are some variations within the dimension and form of the display screen. The Huawei Band 8 has a 1.47-inch AMOLED display screen with a decision of 368 x 194 pixels, whereas the Xiaomi Good Band 8 has a 1.62-inch AMOLED display screen with a decision of 490 x 192 pixels.
The Xiaomi Band 8 ditches its mono-silicon strap in favor of straps that latch on with a brand new mechanism and that permits you to lastly check out totally different model straps, and even use it as a pendant or mount it in your shoe throughout that run as a result of why not!?
Commercial – Proceed studying under
Show
Each units have customizable watch faces that may present varied data comparable to time, date, steps, energy, coronary heart charge, climate, notifications, and extra. You may as well swipe the display screen to entry totally different modes and settings.
The Huawei Band 8 has six watch faces to select from out of the field with many extra out there by way of the Huawei Well being App, whereas the Xiaomi Good Band 8 has 7 watch faces to select from. You may as well obtain extra watch faces from the respective apps.
The panel on the Xiaomi Good Band 8 has a 60Hz refresh charge and my goodness what a distinction does that make? Scrolling the UI feels fluid and clean. The Xiaomi Good Band 8’s display screen is barely bigger however doesn’t really feel prefer it as it’s longer than it’s extensive, making UI parts and textual content should wrap to suit the width.
You may as well create your personal watch face together with your photographs from the companion apps with Huawei donning a brand new characteristic that helps you design a fancy-looking watchface. The Xiaomi Good Band 8 has extra choices and adaptability on the subject of the show, however the Huawei Band 8 has a less complicated and cleaner interface.
Battery Life
Health trackers are identified for his or her endurance, particularly after they’re new earlier than the battery cells begin degrading. The Huawei Band 8 has a battery lifetime of 14 days and is powered by a 180mAh battery. However, the Xiaomi Good Band 8 gives an extended battery lifetime of 16 days and is supplied with a 190mAh battery.
That is theoretical and your mileage would possibly range relying in your utilization and the options you’ve got turned on. In my testing, each trackers lasted a couple of week with All the time on Show enabled within the Automated or Good mode that enables the tracker to show off the characteristic when it isn’t in use like at night time to save lots of on juice.
What would a health tracker be with out the power to trace your exercise? Effectively, these two merchandise are fairly polished on the subject of health monitoring, maybe because of the years of iteration and enchancment that they’ve each seen from the numerous earlier generations.
I’m not probably the most energetic particular person however for the little runs and hikes that I take sometimes, these two observe my steps to round 10% of one another with the Xiaomi Good Band 8 overstating the exercise however not by a lot.
Commercial – Proceed studying under
The Huawei Band 8 gives greater than 100 totally different train modes to trace your actions. These modes embody operating, biking, swimming, basketball, soccer, and lots of extra. The band additionally options the Huawei TruSports algorithm that tracks varied health metrics comparable to operating capability index, VO2Max, restoration time, coaching load, coaching impact, and coronary heart charge.
The Xiaomi Good Band 8 gives greater than 150 totally different train modes to trace your actions however for even probably the most seasons health fanatic, each units observe greater than it is possible for you to to do. Nevertheless, it’s price noting that for a lot of of those train modes, these bands solely log the energy, coronary heart charge, and energy.
Companion App
Each the Mi Health app and Huawei Well being app are decently polished and well-designed with simple methods to work together together with your sensible band. They each supply detailed overview displays of the info that the band tracks.
Nevertheless, I ran right into a small concern the place the Huawei Well being app wasn’t at all times out there on the Google Play Retailer and it could redirect to the Huawei App Gallery for updates which I assumed was just a little odd. No such points exist with the Xiaomi Mi Health app.
Sideloading this on an Android wasn’t that a lot of a trouble however I get why somebody who isn’t too savvy would possibly stumble just a little when putting in and coping with the Huawei product.
Pricing and Availability
The Xiaomi Good Band 8 goes for Ksh 6,800 (175,000 UGX, $46, or 36,000 Naira) whereas the Huawei Band 8 will run you a cool Ksh 7,999 (204,000 UGX, $54, or 43,000 Naira). Whereas these units do have their international or worldwide variations, I might solely supply for the China variants.
Whereas these are fairly much like worldwide variations, there are a number of points like untranslated watchfaces, and apps like Alipay and Weixin Pay which are in-built, can’t be used right here and might’t be uninstalled. Additionally, NFC is just about ineffective.
I additionally bumped into points setting these units up utilizing my current account as I had to enroll in new Huawei and Xiaomi accounts with a Chinese language ID to get these to work.
Commercial – Proceed studying under
Verdict
The Huawei Band 8 and the Xiaomi Good Band 8 are each wonderful sensible bands that may allow you to monitor your well being and health. They’ve related designs, shows, battery lives, sensors, and connectivity options, however in addition they have some variations that may make another appropriate for you than the opposite.
The Huawei Band 8 has a wider display screen that’s extra usable, and a less complicated interface, whereas the Xiaomi Good Band 8 has a bigger display screen, a PAI rating. The Xiaomi Good Band 8 can be barely cheaper than the Huawei Band 8. Finally, the selection relies on your private choice and funds.
After virtually a month of backwards and forwards, I nonetheless don’t have a transparent favourite as these two are very evenly matched. That’s to say that whichever you decide on, you’re in for a deal with, so let worth and your ecosystem choice lead you.
